Ask Mallard
Core concept

Choosing an evidence synthesis approach

4 min read

Choose the review process for your question, then decide whether and how the findings can be combined.

Fit

When it matters, and when it does not

It matters when

  • You must decide whether to map a field or answer a focused evidence question.
  • You need to explain why pooling is appropriate, limited or omitted.

It matters less when

Before you start

What to check in your study

Decide these first
  1. Review purposeChoose mapping, effect estimation, experience or another explicit aim.
  2. Unit of evidenceDecide whether to review primary studies, existing reviews or individual participant data.
  3. Feasible scopeSpecify search coverage, eligible designs and available appraisal time.
It rests on these
  1. The search and selection match the review purpose.How to check: Use explicit eligibility rules and record exclusions.
  2. Any pooled studies address a compatible target.How to check: Compare populations, interventions, outcomes, follow-up and risk of bias before pooling.

Plain language

How it works

A systematic review uses explicit methods to find, select and appraise evidence for a stated question. A scoping review maps concepts, evidence types and gaps. Grant and Booth describe review types; Tricco and colleagues set out scoping review reporting. A rapid review uses declared shortcuts, which may reduce coverage.

What decides the choice
Match the intended question to the approach. Need the shape of a field leads to Scoping review: map the evidence. Need a focused answer leads to Systematic review: find and appraise evidence. Compatible quantitative estimates exist leads to Meta-analysis: optional synthesis step.Choose by the question and available structureNeed the shape of a fieldScoping review: map the evidenceNeed a focused answerSystematic review: find and appraiseevidenceCompatible quantitative estimates existMeta-analysis: optional synthesis stepThese are choice criteria, not a ranking of evidence or a guarantee of validity.
Conceptual diagram. It shows the structure of the idea, not data from any study.
Choosing the approach

An overview reviews existing reviews and must handle overlapping studies. Qualitative synthesis brings together findings about experience or meaning. Meta-analysis is a statistical step that may sit inside a systematic review. Pairwise pooling compares the same contrast; network synthesis compares connected alternatives under stronger assumptions. Individual participant data synthesis changes the data available, not the need for a sound review.

Worked example

A worked example

Invented for illustration
Setting
A team finds 10 eligible trials after a systematic search.
Question
Can all trials support one pooled treatment effect?
Approach
Four trials address the same outcome and horizon. Six use different questions or incompatible outcome definitions.
Result
The comparable subset is 4 of 10 trials, or 40 in 100. The other 6 remain in the review with a structured explanation.
What it means
Eligibility does not guarantee compatibility. Decide whether to pool the four after checking bias and clinical differences; report why the six were not pooled.

In practice

Recent studies PubMed search · not vetted

Searching PubMed…

Watch out

Common mistakes

The one to remember

A systematic review need not contain a meta-analysis. Pooling cannot make incompatible questions comparable. A scoping review maps evidence and does not by itself establish treatment effectiveness.

  • Treating systematic review and meta-analysis as synonyms.Instead: Name the review process and the synthesis separately.
  • Pooling because the software accepts the inputs.Instead: Check the clinical contrast before statistical heterogeneity.
  • Calling a rapid search exhaustive.Instead: Declare each shortcut and its possible effect on coverage.

Inside Mallard

How Mallard uses this

Mallard includes this comparison in Learn search and the Atlas. Plans do not link to this comparison automatically.

No Mallard code example points to this page.
Atlas node concept.choosing_evidence_synthesis_types, the id a plan cue records.

Related Learn pages

Related designs and methods

Evidence

Sources & further reading

  1. A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies (opens in a new tab) · Health Info Libr J · doi 10.1111/j.1471-1842.2009.00848.x
  2. PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): Checklist and Explanation (opens in a new tab) · Ann Intern Med · doi 10.7326/M18-0850
Prepared with AI assistance. PubMed records checked on 2026-11-06 for title, authors, year and DOI. The cited methods support the comparisons; record verification is not independent methodological approval.
Last source review: 2026-11-06
AI-generated educational content
Mallard uses reputable methodological and reporting sources, but this material may contain errors or omit important context. Verify important methodological decisions with the cited sources and, when appropriate, a qualified research methodologist or statistician.