Multistate models
Multistate models follow people through defined health states. They separate the speed of each transition from the chance of being in a state.
Fit
When to use it, and when not to
Use it when
- An intermediate event changes the later course, such as relapse before death.
- You need probabilities of being alive in different health states over time.
Not when
- Only the first event among competing causes matters. A simpler competing-risk model may answer the question. Read: Choosing an analysis for competing risks
- You need the number of repeated events without distinct health states. Consider a recurrent-event model. Read: Choosing an analysis for recurrent events
Before you start
What you need
- States and allowed transitionsMake states distinct and state whether recovery or repeat entry is possible.
- Entry, transition and last-contact timesA state first detected at a visit may have begun earlier; account for interval censoring.
- The probability or transition contrast of interesttargetcompetingEventsSpecify the starting state, time origin and follow-up horizon.
- MCAR excludes dependence on observed or missing values. MAR allows dependence on observed values. MNAR retains dependence on missing values after conditioning.How to check: Relate the assumption to the unobserved outcomes and the history actually recorded.
- The chosen model captures the relevant past.How to check: A Markov model uses the current state and time. A semi-Markov model can also use time since entering that state.
- Transition recording and censoring support the chosen estimator.How to check: Check visit timing, delayed entry and independent censoring given the modeled history.
- Name missing completely at random (MCAR), missing at random (MAR) or missing not at random (MNAR).How to check: If MAR is plausible, consider history-based censoring weights. If MNAR is plausible, vary unobserved transition risks in a sensitivity analysis.
Plain language
How it works
Draw states before choosing a model. Arrows mark allowed transitions; an absorbing state has no outgoing arrow. A transition hazard describes the instantaneous rate among people in its source state. State probabilities combine paths through the system. De Wreede and colleagues developed mstate tools for transition models, probability estimates and their standard errors. Beyersmann and colleagues modeled infection during intensive-care stays rather than treating infection as present at admission.
Aalen-Johansen combines estimated transition hazards into probabilities under appropriate assumptions. Markov transition predictions and probabilities in the original starting cohort need different history assumptions. Report those assumptions and intervals suited to the probability estimator. A Cox coefficient for one transition is not the probability of that transition or state.
Worked example
A worked example
- Setting
- All 100 patients start alive without relapse. Death is absorbing, so no one leaves that state.
- Question
- Where are patients expected to be after two intervals?
- Approach
- In each interval, well patients stay well with probability 0.7, relapse with 0.2, or die with 0.1. Relapsed patients remain relapsed with 0.75; otherwise they die.
- Result
- After two intervals, expected counts are 49 well, 29 relapsed and 22 dead: 22 in 100 dead. All state probabilities sum to 1.
- What it means
- Assume fixed transition probabilities and complete follow-up. Death can occur with or without relapse; the relapse-to-death probability alone is not the overall death risk.
In practice
Recent studies PubMed search · not vetted
Watch out
Common mistakes
The one to remember
A transition hazard is not a probability of occupying a state. When death prevents the event, one minus Kaplan-Meier overstates cumulative incidence. Define every allowed transition and justify any assumption that future risk depends only on the current state.
- Reading a transition hazard as a state probability.Instead: Combine all allowed paths to calculate state probabilities from the specified starting state and time.
- Censoring competing deaths in a risk curve.Instead: Use cumulative incidence for competing outcomes. One minus Kaplan-Meier overstates incidence when death prevents the event.
- Applying a Markov assumption without checking the disease course.Instead: Consider time since entry and earlier events. Use a model and probability estimator appropriate to that history.
Inside Mallard
How Mallard uses this
Plans do not link to this method yet. Mallard has no dedicated multistate sizing form.
analysis.multistate, the id a plan cue records.Related Learn pages
Related designs and methods
Evidence
Sources & further reading
- The mstate package for estimation and prediction in non- and semi-parametric multi-state and competing risks models (opens in a new tab) · Comput Methods Programs Biomed · doi 10.1016/j.cmpb.2010.01.001
- Transmission-associated nosocomial infections: prolongation of intensive care unit stay and risk factor analysis using multistate models (opens in a new tab) · Am J Infect Control · doi 10.1016/j.ajic.2007.06.007